| Platinum | Not Just Cakes |
| Gold | The Farmer's Pantry |
| Silver | Parisotto's Pizzeria & Bakery |
| Bronze | Harold's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Cedar House Bakery and Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Miner's Daughter Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sinful Sweets |
| Top Pick | The Cake Pop Tree |
| Top Pick | The Mad Batter |
| Top Pick | Tony's Bakery |