| Platinum | 7 By 7 Restaurant |
| Gold | Parisotto's Pizzeria & Bakery |
| Silver | East Side Mario's |
| Bronze | The Olive Tree Pizzeria Bistro |
| Top Pick | A & R Eatery |
| Top Pick | Eatza Pizza at Troys |
| Top Pick | Jane's Restaurant & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Kenny's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Napoli Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Skip The Kitchen |